Working With Clients Who Self-Diagnose: A Digital Age Double-Edged Sword

In a cozy, dimly lit counselling room, Emma sits across from me, her eyes brimming with hope and apprehension. She has come to see me after months of wrestling with what she believes to be severe anxiety and depression. As she clutches a printout of her latest online self-assessment, Emma confesses, “I’ve read so much online, and I’m sure I have both. I need to know how to manage this.”

In the digital age, where information is abundant and the line between professional and self-diagnosis often blurs, her declaration has become increasingly common.

The Rise of Self-Diagnosis in the Digital Age

The internet has revolutionized how we access information, including health-related content. With just a few clicks, individuals can find a wealth of resources on mental health conditions, symptoms, and treatment options. This democratization of information has its benefits, particularly in reducing stigma and promoting awareness. However, it also comes with significant challenges, especially when clients present with self-diagnoses based on their online research.

Self-diagnosis can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it can empower individuals to seek help and take control of their mental health. On the other, it can lead to misdiagnosis, increased anxiety, and a reliance on potentially unreliable sources of information. Mental health professionals must navigate this landscape with sensitivity and expertise.

The internet has revolutionized how we access information, including health-related content.

Understand the Motivations Behind Those Who Self-Diagnose

When a client like Emma comes in with a self-diagnosis, it is essential to understand her motivation. Often, clients turn to the internet looking for understanding and relief. They may have experienced symptoms for a long time and are now seeking validation and answers. For some, self-diagnosis can be a way to make sense of their experiences and feel less alone.

7 Steps to Meet Self-Diagnosis With Sensitivity and Expertise

1. Build Trust and Open Communication

1. The first step in working with clients who self-diagnose is to build a foundation of trust and open communication. Acknowledge their efforts to understand their mental health and validate their feelings. It is important not to dismiss their concerns outright, as this can lead to defensiveness and hinder the therapeutic process.

For example, with Emma, I acknowledged her initiative in seeking information about her symptoms. I expressed my understanding of how overwhelming it can be to navigate mental health issues and commended her for taking steps toward seeking professional help.

2. Conduct a Thorough Assessment

After establishing trust, it is vital to conduct a thorough assessment. This involves gathering comprehensive information about the client’s symptoms, history, and overall functioning. While self-assessments and online quizzes can provide some insights, they are not substitutes for a professional evaluation.

During the assessment, I gently guided Emma through a detailed exploration of her symptoms, their duration, and their impact on her daily life. This process helped to differentiate between various potential diagnoses and understand the nuances of her experiences.

By explaining the diagnostic criteria, the role of differential diagnosis, and the importance of a holistic approach, therapists can help clients appreciate the value of a professional assessment.

3. Educate Clients About the Diagnostic Process

Educating clients about the diagnostic process is key. Many may not fully understand the complexity of mental health diagnoses and the factors considered by professionals. By explaining the diagnostic criteria, the role of differential diagnosis, and the importance of a holistic approach, therapists can help clients appreciate the value of a professional assessment.

In Emma’s case, I explained the diagnostic criteria for anxiety and depression, as well as how these conditions can sometimes overlap with other mental health issues. I also emphasized the importance of examining her general well-being, life circumstances, and other contributing factors.

4. Validate Experiences While Providing Professional Insights

Balancing validation with professional insights is crucial. It is important to validate the client’s experiences and feelings while gently challenging any misconceptions or inaccuracies in their self-diagnosis. You can achieve this by framing the conversation around a collaborative exploration of their symptoms and experiences.

With Emma, I validated her feelings of anxiety and sadness, acknowledging that these were real and distressing experiences. I then introduced the idea that while her self-diagnosis was a starting point, our work together would involve a deeper exploration to ensure that we fully understood her unique situation.

5. Empower Clients Through Collaborative Care

Collaborative care empowers clients by actively involving them in the treatment planning process. This can help to build their confidence in the therapeutic process and promote a sense of agency. Working together to develop a treatment plan allows clients to feel heard and respected.

For Emma, we discussed various treatment options, including cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT), mindfulness techniques, and potentially exploring medication with a psychiatrist. She felt more in control of her treatment with this collaborative approach, which reassured her of the seriousness of her concerns.

Collaborative care empowers clients by actively involving them in the treatment planning process.

6. Address the Impact of Online Information

Another important aspect of working with clients who self-diagnose is to discuss the reliability of different sources while guiding them to credible, evidence-based resources. This can mitigate the risk of misinformation and reduce anxiety stemming from unreliable information.

I provided Emma with a list of reputable websites and resources, explaining how to evaluate the credibility of online content. We also discussed the potential pitfalls of relying solely on the internet for mental health information, along with the benefits of seeking professional guidance.

7. The Role of Continuous Support and Reassessment

Working with clients who self-diagnose is an ongoing process that requires continued support and reassessment. Mental health is dynamic, and clients’ needs and symptoms can change with time. Regular check-ins and reassessments ensure that the treatment plan remains relevant and effective.

Throughout our sessions, I continued to monitor Emma’s progress and reassess her symptoms. This allowed us to make necessary adjustments to her treatment plan and address any new concerns

Conclusion

In the digital age, self-diagnosis has become a common phenomenon that mental health professionals must navigate with care and expertise. By understanding what motivates self-diagnosis, therapists can effectively work with clients while building trust, conducting thorough assessments, and providing education. Balancing validation with professional insights, and empowering clients through collaborative care are essential components of this process.

Emma’s journey in therapy highlights the importance of a nuanced approach. By acknowledging her self-diagnosis while guiding her through a comprehensive assessment and treatment plan, we were able to address her mental health needs more effectively. For therapists, the key lies in blending empathy with professional expertise, fostering a therapeutic environment where clients feel understood, supported, and empowered to embark on their path to healing.

A Personal Reflection

Working with clients like Emma has deepened my appreciation for the complexities of mental health in the digital age. It has taught me the value of empathy, patience, and continuous learning. As therapists, our role is not just to diagnose and treat, but to walk alongside our clients. We’re there to help them navigate the vast landscape of information and misinformation, and ultimately find their way to genuine understanding and healing.

In addition to my work with CTRI, I run a private practice. Learn how we support clients at Shelly Qualtieri & Associates

---

Still Curious?

If you want to learn more about this topic, check out some of our related resources and products..

On-Demand Workshop

Our workshop, Brief Focused Counselling Skills examines strategies from leading frameworks.

Blog

Supporting Youth Mental Health in the Digital Age

On-Demand Webinar

This 1-hr webinar is an introduction and overview of Solution Focused Therapy

Podcast

Tune in once a month for authentic and insightful conversations on a variety of counselling topics.

Share this: